vineri, 26 iunie 2015

Second meeting

Dear students,

Welcome to our second meeting! 

For today I have in mind a serious debate on the purpose of art. I urge you to think hard and give me a mature, sensible answer to this question:

"What is the purpose of art?"

As guideline you can read the following quote from Oscar Wilde and use it as a starting point:

"The artist is the creator of beautiful things. To reveal art and conceal the artist is art's aim. [...] There is no such thing as a moral or an immoral book. Books are well written, or badly written. That is all. [...] It is the spectator, and not life, that art really mirrors. [...]
We can forgive a man for making a useful thing as long as he does not admire it. The only excuse for making a useless thing is that one admires it intensely.
All art is quite useless." Oscar Wilde - Preface to 'The Picture of Dorian Gray'

I know that this topic is a bit difficult, but I trust that you can give
me an opinion on it. And I will be right here to help you along. 
Yours,
Teacher






43 de comentarii:

  1. Art does not have to have a purpose - it does not exist in order to teach, to urge a moral point, to entertain, to distract, to amuse, to serve beauty, to support a revolution, to disgust, to challenge, to stimulate or to cheer; it exists chiefly for its own sake. It is the artist, not art as such, that may have an aim in mind, and his aim may be to do any of the things just listed.
    Oscar Wild said in his book: “If a man treats a life artistically, his brain is his heart.” (you know, you love with your heart, but take the brain with you).
    The thing is, a book is written on the thoughts of the one who writes. It mirrors him. His wishes, dreams, behaviour, HIS thoughts. But, I don't really think art is ''quite useless''. Art is a form of expressing yourself, even by painting, music, writing. All your feelings are there, and I think it is good for us, people, to write down our thoughts by any form. So, no. Art is not ''quite useless''. At least for me.

    RăspundețiȘtergere
  2. I think art causes people to look a little closer. To look closer at the social issues, at other people and their emotions, at the environment that surround them, and the everyday objects and life forms around them. It helps them see what is there but not easily perceived. The artist brings out that which cannot be seen or felt easily.
    When society sees and feels clearly on these things, it provides opportunities for change in thought or appreciation of the message behind the art.
    Art is usually about self-expression.

    RăspundețiȘtergere
    Răspunsuri
    1. So, O.W. is not right in saying "To reveal art and conceal the artist is art's aim."?

      Ștergere
    2. So, O.W. is not right in saying "To reveal art and conceal the artist is art's aim."?

      Ștergere
    3. But you concluded that art is about self-expression. You express contradictory ideas because if art is about self-expression then it reveals the artist, it does not conceal him as O.W.says...

      Ștergere
    4. Did you make up your mind, Fabi?

      Ștergere
    5. Oh, sorry.
      From my point of view, he is not right, because, how I said, art is usually about self-expression because the artist must tell to the world what he feels. It must not conceal him.
      I think so..

      Ștergere
    6. I will try to explain to you how I understand that sentence. I think that what O.W. wants to say is that we must place art above the artist simply because art is universal and it crosses the boundaries of the time when it was written, whereas the artist does not.
      But to place the creation above the creator is unfair, because you can't ignore the talent and the effort that went into that piece of art.
      So I agree with you, not with Oscar Wilde.

      Ștergere
    7. I have another question for you: what purpose does art have for people who are not artists ( for non-artists so to say)?

      Ștergere
    8. Hmm, I think it makes them think better, to feel more intense, to improve their imagination, to understand the world.

      Ștergere
    9. Do you know what catharsis is? It roughly means "purification through art". This is one of the purposes of art for the non-artist, wouldn't you agree?

      Ștergere
    10. Let's leave the serious discussion aside and enjoy something lighter. You deserve a good laugh after such deep thinking. Watch this on youtube: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OgFHYteJSPk&hd=1. You'll split your sides laughing.

      Ștergere
    11. That was really funny, thank you teacher.

      Ștergere
    12. 'Kofi', 'Hu'. Daaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaamn.

      Ștergere
    13. I'm glad you liked it. As you can see, English can be quite a challenge even for native speakers.

      Ștergere
  3. You express a very bold point of view, Melissa. What O.W. meant by "All art is quite useless" was that art is not utilitarian, i.e. it cannot be used as an instrument in pursuit of a certain goal. Without even realising it, you agree with O.W.

    RăspundețiȘtergere
    Răspunsuri
    1. If this matters, I'm gonna devorate this book! It is absolutely brilliant. And thank you.

      Ștergere
    2. I think you mean DEVOUR. And which book? The Picture of Dorian Gray? Do you have it?

      Ștergere
    3. Yeah, that's what I mean. Sorry.
      Yes, ''The picture of Dorian Gray''. No, I found it on the internet. I'm used with reading online. I also found on tumblr some very very beautiful quotes from the book.

      Ștergere
    4. This book is the one that made me fall in love with English. Before reading it, I liked English, afterwards I loved it with a passion that only increased with the passage of time. In this novel you will find English in one of its purest and most exquisite expressions.

      Ștergere
    5. Do you have any idea why there are only 3 of us on this blog today? For instance, I would have wanted Marius's view on the topic. After all, he is the closest we have to an artist in our group... And where is Bianca? she didn't even take the listening test...

      Ștergere
    6. I'll read it online. I found it translated in Romanian but I don't want to read it that way. And it has only 200 pages, even 100, so this is a big no.

      Ștergere
    7. I just want to warn you that there is not much of a story in the book. This novel is an example of "art for art's sake", so it is to be read simply because it is beautiful.

      Ștergere
    8. I don't know what Marius is doing. And Bianca..she's not interested. She said to me that she won't be here ''just to read what we post''. I don't know. I told her what we're doing here, but..

      Ștergere
    9. I've figured it out. As I said, I found some quotes on Tumblr that just, kind of broke my heart. There was that feeling and I liked it instantly.

      Ștergere
    10. I'm not telling them to be here anymore. The first time I told to some of them to get in here and solve the exercises we do. But not anymore. who wants to be here, will be. So.

      Ștergere
    11. It's a good thing you and Fabi know what loyalty is. Loyalty to English...

      Ștergere
    12. there is another thing I do not understand and maybe you can explain it to me. Why is it that there are 2 or 3 of us here talking and writing, but the number of our views keeps growing exponentially?

      Ștergere
    13. Maybe more of us have seen the post and probably are writing their opinion.

      Ștergere
    14. Why aren't they posting it then? I wrote a question for Fabi above. He hasn't answered yet. See what you can do about it...

      Ștergere
    15. I don't know. Look again, he answered.

      Ștergere
    16. But you didn't. After you do, watch the video I recommended to Fabi.

      Ștergere
    17. Ohh. Sorry. Ok, so. From what you told us, catharsis is a purification through art. Like me, for example, when I'm sad or happy and I try to write down a poem, or take some photos then editing them. Or just reading stuff? Is that right?

      Ștergere
    18. Right. When you listen to soft music to calm down, or, to rock music to simply let off steam because you are angry.
      When you read a Sherlock Holmes novel just because you want to feel like a detective (because in real life you are a teacher and you deal with children, not criminals).
      Art offers an aesthetic experience from which you emerge as an enriched, purified version of yourself.

      Ștergere
  4. Art never come from happiness that is what an elder artist told me sometimes, and i understand what he tried to tell me than, art is the way used by people to express their deepest feelings, fears, thoughts, it is just the best way to keep your mind, soul and body healthy. For me art is my life, without art i don t exist, and without me my art don t exist, it is simple, art is my greater quality, but is also my biggest weakness..

    RăspundețiȘtergere
    Răspunsuri
    1. This is what I wanted to read from you. I would have hoped for better English (especially verb tenses and forms), but I understood the essence.

      Ștergere
  5. And i did not knew that we have a meeting today, i thought that the next meeting is on 26 july, not june, sorry..and i was playing lol.

    RăspundețiȘtergere
    Răspunsuri
    1. Well, you got it wrong because you weren't paying attention. Don't let it happen again! And why are you letting games stand in the way of your art?

      Ștergere
    2. Games are my inspiration <3, it will not happen again :3

      Ștergere